Not asking why it resonates

Description

  • You have no idea why people like it, but it do be shiftin’

Disproof

  • Large-scale post-acquisition data on what the product means to the user and how they learned that meaning

Consequences

  • Success without understanding is luck, and luck runs out
  • Despite there being no immediate risks, this creates hubris/complacency
  • You won’t understand your customer better and miss opportunities to better serve them or solve other problems for them
  • You won’t develop the skills to position the next product, over-reach and die
  • The next shiny thing comes along and you lose your users

Causes

  • No culture of understanding what drove success
  • Satisficing biases - you think you know why people like it, read a few happy tweets from a fraction of your user base and don’t question it further
  • “Of course it’s awesome, we made it”
  • Time pressure to move on to the next one

Approaches

  • Frankly, it’s very hard to fight a rising market and it might be better conserving strength to act when things start to go wrong